How Pope Benedict fared in America

What happened
Pope Benedict XVI returned to Rome on Monday after a six-day U.S. visit that included a meeting with President Bush and stop in New York City to bless the ground at ground zero, where the World Trade Center towers stood until the Sept. 11, 2001, terrorist attacks. The German-born pope was met with loud cheers in his last Mass, at Yankee Stadium, after a trip in which he repeatedly referred to the sexual abuse scandal that has wracked the U.S. church. (Voice of America)

What the commentators said
Pope Benedict was seen as a "stay-at-home, traditional guardian of church doctrine" when he was elected, said The Boston Globe in an editorial, but "it turns out he travels well." Benedict came to prominence as a theologian, but he “connected with Americans of many faiths through his simple preaching and pastoral work. Whether addressing diplomats at the United Nations or praying with victims of clergy sexual abuse in a Washington chapel, he took exquisite care to uphold the dignity of every person.”

Not everyone was impressed, said The Wall Street Journal in an editorial. "Anti-immigrant obsessive" Rep. Tom Tancredo and "Tancredo-like compulsive" Lou Dobbs attracted international attention for "insulting the spiritual leader of one in four Americans." The pope had called on his church to continue to welcome immigrants, which led Dobbs to accuse the pope of "insulting our country" with his "bad manners," and Tancredo to complain of the pontiff's "faith-based marketing." But Pope Benedict "isn't 'marketing' his faith. He's practicing it."

Whether he meant for it to be or not, though, his trip was a "PR coup," said Marshall Loeb in MarketWatch. And "leaders of business, government, academe, the military and our other basic institutions" would do well to pay attention. Benedict faced up to the problems that have torn up the U.S. church with candor, and showed that leaders should never “try to dodge the truth, no matter how awful it may be or whom it may implicate.” Apologize for “past misdeeds and beg forgiveness,” and the healing can begin.

digg del.icio.us stumbleUpon newsvine reddit furl

Comment on this article

Recent comments | 1 total

Gabrielle Azzaro | Thursday, July 3, 2008, 1:11 pm

The question is not how we all \"fared\" but what will the pope do now that he has \"apologized?\" Will he actually follow up with ACTION, or were they simply nice words that made for good vatican press? He did not really \"face up to the problems that have torn up the US Church,\" he uttered sweet-sounding words. Did he take any accountability for his own part in it while he was Cardinal Ratzinger? Meeting with a few hand-picked victims instead of inviting them all to a gathering like he did priests and religious was simply another media ploy to make him look sympathetic and human. Sorry, those of us who have been victimized know better. Pretty words and weak gestures are what got the church in this mess to begin with. The question is \"How is Benedict going to get us out??!!\"