Apple's Foxconn probe: Will it improve brutal working conditions?

After coming under fire over punishing practices at the Foxconn factories in China where iPhones are made, Apple CEO Tim Cook calls for a third-party investigation

Best Opinion:  IBT, eWeek, TechCrunch

Apple announced on Monday that it was asking the nonprofit Fair Labor Association (FLA) to investigate the reportedly hazardous working conditions at the Foxconn manufacturing plants in China, where many Apple gadgets are made. CEO Tim Cook's call comes after a detailed exposé in The New York Times and a nationally syndicated story on NPR, both spotlighting brutal working conditions in the Chinese factories — from relentless 12-hour, seven-day-a-week shifts to awful wages to a hauntingly high number of suicides. Do Cook and Apple deserve credit for stepping up?

Give Apple credit: A third-party investigation is "exactly what the doctor ordered," says Dave Smith at the International Business Times. Under former CEO Steve Jobs, one of Apple's more unsettling traits was its ability to "distort reality," oftentimes "spinning negative news into positive news and positive news into extraordinary news." Cook understands that in this case, "his company could not come clean if it didn't look for outside help." That level-headedness is an asset, and "that's why Apple, and all Apple users, should thank Tim Cook." 
"Apple approves Foxconn investigation: Why Tim Cook deserves credit"

But it's not nearly enough: The "good news" is that Apple is finally taking action, says Wayne Rash at eWeek. The "bad news" is that Chinese workers are unlikely to see improvement anytime soon. Even if violations are found, there isn't much Apple can do. There's "little in the way" of actual enforcement mechanisms. The sad truth is that once the inspection results are revealed on FLA's website, "Foxconn will revert to business as usual." 
"Foxconn inspections are good PR, but Apple needs to protect workers"

And the problem is bigger than Apple and Foxconn: "This is about economics," says John Biggs at TechCrunch. Sure, Apple is sending in the FLA to investigate. But cheap labor is the reason China's economy is exploding, and "what Shenzen makes, the world takes." Once the smoke clears, these factories will revert to their horrible conditions, and Apple will continue to sell truckloads of iPads. This isn't a Foxconn-only problem — it's the whole manufacturing industry. This probe merely (and ineffectively) inspects "the canopy of the tree while ignoring the disease-infested trunk."
"False alarm: Why the Apple/Foxconn debacle clouds the real manufacturing mess"

see comments

Can iPads replace textbooks?

Apple has unveiled a grand plan to revolutionize the education industry with iBooks 2.0

In a bid to reinvent the education industry, Apple on Thursday announced an app called iBooks 2.0 that allows educators and authors to create interactive textbooks for use on the iPad. Major publishers, including McGraw-Hill, Pearson, and Houghton Mifflin Harcourt... More

Will iPad 3 rumors ruin Apple's Christmas?

A fresh round of rumors about a new tablet on the horizon is threatening the tech giant's holiday sales

DigiTimes, a website based in Taipei, reported Monday that a new iPad is going into production early next year and set to be released in March or April. The tech world quickly seized on the report. With Christmas less than two weeks away, will these iPad 3 rumors... More

iTunes Match: A 'game-changer' for music listeners?

Techies can't decide whether Apple's new cloud music service is surprisingly revolutionary or hopelessly old school

On Monday, after weeks of frantic anticipation from tech fans, Apple launched its iTunes Match service. For $24.99 a year, the cloud music service allows users to listen to their music collection on multiple devices, no matter where the music files are stored.... More

Should Steve Jobs be TIME’s 'Person of the Year'?

The magazine that gave the award to "You" in 2006 and "the computer" in 1982 has never honored a deceased person. Is now the time to break the rules?

Earlier this week, TIME unveiled some unofficial nominees for 2011's "Person of the Year" award, and as expected, Apple icon Steve Jobs was on the list. His competition? Elizabeth Warren (the consumer advocate running for Senate in Massachusetts), Mohamed Bouazizi... More

Steve Jobs' final project: A 'revolutionary' Apple TV set?

According to a new biography, the late Apple icon had figured out a way to change the way we watch television

The late Steve Jobs revolutionized the way we interact with data and music with his focus on an elegant interface and clean, simple design. According to the new biography, Steve Jobs by Walter Isaacson, the Apple icon next planned to change the way we watch television... More