How badly will Iran's oil 'blackmail' hurt Europe?

Tehran cuts off oil shipments to the U.K. and France in retaliation for Western sanctions over Iran's nuclear program. Is this bad for the EU ... or Iran?

Best Opinion:  Daily Beast, Reuters, Outcome

Iran has cut off oil shipments to France and Britain in retaliation for tough new sanctions from Europe, which, starting July 1, will impose an embargo on Iranian oil, a crucial source of revenue for Tehran, in an attempt to force Iran to curb its nuclear program. Iran also threatened to stop oil sales to Spain, Greece, Italy, Portugal, Germany, and the Netherlands if they remain "hostile" to Tehran, sending oil prices to a nine-month high. How badly will Iran's latest gambit hurt Europe?

The damage to Europe could be severe: Iran's "blackmail" could work, says Niall Ferguson at The Daily Beast. Europe isn't a giant importer of Iranian oil, but some of Tehran's biggest European customers — Spain, Italy, and Greece — are in dire shape. "If even the rumor of an Iranian export ban could send the price of oil above $120 a barrel, what would a full-scale showdown between Iran and Israel do? Answer: It would inflict yet more economic misery on Europe, which gives Brussels a big incentive" to go easier on Iran.
"Iran uses European oil dependence as blackmail on nukes"

Actually, this will blow over: Iran can't do much damage by cutting oil shipments to the U.K. and France, says Kevin Allison at Reuters. Neither relies much on Iranian oil in the first place, and they've had plenty of time to line up alternative supplies in recent weeks. The stock market barely blinked when Iran decided to pre-empt Europe's embargo, because investors know prices will drift back down from $120 a barrel soon. It would take something "much bigger to create a real problem."
"Higher oil price should burn itself out"

This might hurt Iran most of all: Iran has been threatening to do this for weeks, says Outcome Magazine, but it held off because it knows that "ceasing all exports to the EU would harm its own economy" unless it can line up replacement buyers in Asia. After all, Europe buys 20 percent of Iran's crude. And Iran's decision may not hurt Europe at all now that Saudi Arabia — a U.S. ally and Iran rival — has promised to "pump more oil to compensate" for the loss of Iran's crude.
"Iran threatens to cut oil to more EU nations"

see comments

Would Israel attack Iran without U.S. approval?

Ehud Barak and Co. are ratcheting up their rhetoric as Iran's nuclear program continues unchecked — and many U.S. officials don't think our allies are bluffing

Israeli leaders are delivering their "bluntest warnings" yet of possible airstrikes to disable Iran's nuclear program, something the U.S. and other Western leaders fear would uncork dangerous turmoil in the Middle East. Israeli Defense Minister Ehud Barak says... More

Iran's nuclear threat: Can inspections defuse the tensions?

Many Western diplomats hope their worst fears won't be confirmed as international nuclear experts arrive in Iran for a fact-finding mission

A team of inspectors from the International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA) began a potentially crucial three-day visit to Iran on Sunday. Tehran's top diplomat said he was confident that talks between inspectors and Iranian officials would soothe foreign leaders,... More

Will Europe's Iranian oil embargo backfire?

The EU's vow to stop buying millions of barrels of oil a day from Tehran could have a devastating effect on Iran's economy

Taking a cue from the U.S., the European Union is trying to force Tehran to rein in its nuclear program by imposing damaging new sanctions on Iran, banning imports of Tehran's cash cow, oil. Iran, the world's third largest oil exporter, reacted angrily, renewing... More

Are sanctions starting to 'bite' Iran?

New measures designed to cut into Tehran's financial lifeline — its oil revenue — may be shaking Iran's economy and unnerving its ruling mullahs

The new sanctions Iran provoked with its defiant nuclear program are starting to "bite," says the Obama administration, citing Tehran's increasingly belligerent rhetoric. After President Obama signed a bill on New Year's Eve calculated to cut into Iran's oil trade... More

Iran's 'alarming' nuclear fuel-rod claim

Tehran warns the West that its nuclear program has made a giant leap forward. How worried should we be?

Iran announced Sunday that its scientists had produced the country's first nuclear fuel rods. If true, the "alarming" development would mark a big advance in Iran's ability to create nuclear energy or nuclear weapons. The news came as President Obama signed legislation... More